| | | | |

They’re Gonna Judge You Anyway… Part 2: Yes, Even the Naked Ones

Judgment in naturist spaces. A woman lounging nude by a pool, soaking up the sun while comfortably in a naturist setting.

In “part 1“, we talked about judgment from external sources. But what happens with judgment in naturist spaces?

We naturists love to say it. We say it at meetups, we post it online, we sprinkle it all over brochures like fairy dust: “Naturism is a non-judgmental space.”

And sure, it sounds wonderful. It’s comforting. It’s welcoming. It’s… well, it’s also not entirely true.

Because here’s the naked truth: Naturists judge. We judge all the time.

The only difference is, we’re not wearing anything while we do it.

The Big Myth: The Magical Judgment-Free Zone

Let’s be honest here.

The myth of the judgment-free naturist space is one of those things we want to believe in. It feels good to tell newcomers: “Come as you are! No one here cares what you look like!”

And to be fair, that part is often true. Most naturists genuinely don’t care about stretch marks, scars, wrinkles, or what gravity has done to your body.

But here’s the thing: we don’t stop judging entirely. We just switch to judging different things.

We judge behavior. We judge attitude. We judge whether you “fit.” We judge whether you’re one of us… or one of them.

And sometimes… we judge just because we’re bored and humans are weird like that.

The Naturist Judgment Olympics (Oh Yes, They Exist)

If you’ve spent more than an afternoon at a naturist event, you already know: We have categories of judgment. We might as well hand out medals.

Here are a few of the most popular events:

The Gawker Hunt: Who’s staring too long? Is that man actually reading that book or just peeking over the pages every two seconds? Is that couple pretending not to watch everyone else? (Oh yes, we see you watching us… watching you… watching us.

The Etiquette Audit: Towel always on the chair? No shoes in the hot tub? Did they rinse before entering the pool? Did they dare double dip at the potluck table?

The Authenticity Test: Are they real naturists or “textile tourists”? Do they only come when it’s blazing hot and bail when it’s breezy? Do they talk too much about “freedom” but keep checking their phones for Instagram likes?

The PDA Patrol: Oh no… they’re holding hands! Did she just kiss his shoulder? We’re filing this under: “That’s fine… until it’s not.”

Judgment Isn’t Always a Bad Thing (Seriously)

Now, here’s where we take a breath and get honest with ourselves: Judgment gets a bad rap, but it isn’t inherently negative.

A better word for it is discernment.

We all assess situations for our comfort and safety. Especially in a space where everyone’s vulnerable by default.

We need to judge. Is that person making others uncomfortable? Are they respecting boundaries? Are they treating nudity as a shared comfort, not a sexual opportunity?

Frankly, naturist spaces wouldn’t work without a little judgment.

It’s how we maintain respect, keep the atmosphere safe, and… let’s face it, preserve the vibe.

The Weird Side of Judgment In Naturist Spaces (Because Of Course We Have One)

And now we reach the fun part… the weird, wonderfully human ways we judge each other in naturist circles.

We’ve seen it all: The guy who wears a massive straw hat, flip-flops, and a fanny pack, but nothing else. Is this fashion? Or performance art?

The woman who spends her whole day adjusting her beach chair angles like she’s solving a geometry equation.

The couple who always forgets their towels but brings an entire folding table of snack platters.

The people who subtly form tribes based on camping gear quality, smoothie ingredients, or how many naked hiking photos they’ve posted online.

And yes, someone will judge you for bringing store-bought hummus to the potluck. There are no saints here. Only humans… with very high standards for chickpeas.

What’s The Point?

We don’t tell you all this to be cynical. Quite the opposite.

We think naturism works best when we drop the myth of “we’re all perfectly non-judgmental.” Because when we’re honest about our very human quirks, it actually makes the whole thing feel more approachable.

The point isn’t to eliminate judgment. It’s to focus our judgment on things that actually matter: Respect. Consent. Kindness. Community-mindedness.

And maybe, just maybe, we can lighten up about the rest of it.

Our Final Thought (Because Of Course We Have One)

Naturism isn’t about pretending we’re above judgment. It’s about choosing what’s worth judging… and trying to keep it playful, compassionate, and maybe a little ridiculous.

After all… the only creatures who truly don’t judge anyone at the naturist resort? The squirrels.

And honestly, we’re not even sure about them.


We hope you enjoy our human experiences in naturism. Please share, like, leave a comment and subscribe to get notified when we post something new.

You can also “Buy us a Coffee” if you liked our article!

An abstract design featuring the text 'Ko-fi' in a playful font with a heart symbol, representing a platform for supporting creators.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Similar Posts

14 Comments

  1. Yep, I too judge bodies in nudist environments. I like to think that I mostly just “notice” rather than “judge”, but there’s one thing in particular that I always find myself judging: tan lines!

    Not that it’s right, but I do it. I guess it falls in line with your “authenticity test”: I wonder how their bodies have such distinct tan lines if they’re “real” nudists. I also feel bad for them, as if I noticed their tattoo has a spelling error or something. I just love a more natural look, and cringe at how artificial tan lines make the body look.

    I know it’s not right of me – I’m guilty.

  2. “But here’s the thing: we don’t stop judging entirely. We just switch to judging different things. We judge behavior. We judge attitude. We judge whether you “fit.” We judge whether you’re one of us… or one of them.”

    That’s true to a point, but don’t think for one moment that we don’t actually continue to judge bodies! We notice an overweight person or someone that hasn’t looked after their health. We don’t speak it out loud, of course, because that would be seen as judging! But the judgement still happens in our thoughts. However, that doesn’t mean we’re not accepting and welcoming. The internalised judgement might only be fleeting.

    Even the guy with the massive straw hat, flip-flops, and a fanny pack – do we ever stop to consider that it may be neither fashion nor performance art? It may be for totally practical reasons – to prevent sunstroke, prickles in the feet, and a place to carry the car keys.

    How about well-meaning compliments on how great someone looks? That’s maybe something for Part 3?

    1. I am not slim. I don’t judge others for the size of their body. Bodies are not proof of health. You can’t see chronic illness. You can’t see genetics. You can’t see trauma or medication side effects. And the idea that someone’s body tells the story of whether they’ve “taken care of themselves” is rooted in both ableism and fatphobia, not reality. That internal judgment, even if it’s “fleeting,” still comes from a place of social conditioning that we need to unlearn. Naturism gives us the chance to do that work. But only if we’re honest about how deeply those assumptions are baked in.

      1. The thing is that the word “judge” carries a whole lot of different meanings depending on the context. Sure, you don’t judge others for the size of their body. Neither do I. That implies a judgement from a position of perceived superiority. But that doesn’t mean you don’t notice something about a person’s body. And sure , as you say, there are many things about a body that you can’t see. But there are most certainly things that you can see.

        Sure – you are not slim. I would say you are thick set and solidly built, going by your photos. I woudn’t say you’re obese. Hey – I’ve just judged your body! I hope you weren’t offended.

        Noticing a person struggling with unchecked obesity is not “fatphobia” per se. It’s only fatphobia when it involves prejudice, discrimination, and antagonism directed at the person. In our group we have a number of people suffering from health conditions that are visible, including obesity. When I first met them and welcomed them into our group I could see their difficulty. That is making a judgement call. Not in a nasty way, but it’s judgement all the same. I reject your assertion that it “comes from a place of social conditioning that we need to unlearn.” In fact, we’ve set up a fitness regime that we participate in together twice a week, to encourage them to address it. I’m not obese myself, but I enjoy working with these folks and seeing their enthusiasm and massive improvement in their self esteem.

        Bodies are not proof of health? Sure – most times that’s true. But not always. Obesity can be a killer. What you can see is only a part of the problem. Carrying a bit of fat on the tummy and thighs isn’t the problem, but it’s an indication of the presence of visceral fat that is a massive health risk, including heart failure, diabetes, and much more.

        1. Thanks for continuing this conversation. This is the kind of honest back-and-forth that naturism needs. And you’re absolutely right that words like “judgment” are loaded. There is a difference between noticing and judging. Noticing is neutral. Judgment carries weight. The trouble is, many people say “just noticing” when they’ve already attached values to what they see.

          Let’s be clear… health is personal, complex, and deeply individual. You say you “noticed” someone struggling with obesity and then helped them improve their self-esteem with a group fitness regime. That’s great if it was welcomed and self-directed. But for many people, being seen through the lens of needing improvement, especially by strangers or acquaintances, can feel like their body is being evaluated, not accepted.

          And here’s where our disagreement lies. You reject the idea that some of these judgments come from conditioning. We stand by that completely. They do. Our culture bombards us with ideas about what healthy looks like, what attractive looks like, and what “taking care of yourself” looks like. It’s very hard not to absorb those messages, even when our intent is kind.

          We’re not denying that some health risks are correlated with body size. But correlation is not causation, and individual experience matters more than statistics when it comes to how we treat one another. We all see things… but how we interpret what we see, and whether we allow people to define their own wellness, dignity, and worth, is what really matters.

          For us, naturism isn’t about seeing bodies and sorting them into health categories. It’s about showing up as whole people, flawed, varied, aging, scarred, fat, thin, tired, vibrant, whatever, and learning not to flinch, not to compare, and not to assume we know someone else’s story by looking.

  3. Dear OurNaturistLife:

    Your two articles on Judgement were thoughtful and appreciated. I have been wonderfully educated on some of the Challenges that face nakedness. I appreciate your articles and this newsletter.

    Marc

  4. A very interesting look at judgement as it pertains to the nudist community. Never thought about it but you are very spot on about how nudists use judgment differently than textiles. Thank you, Kevin. Jan&Gary 👍❤️

  5. According to my wife, and contrary to “popular opinion”, nudist women consistently and generally judge each other. “Who put on a little weight since last season”, “who used to shave but clearly stopped” (and vice-versa), “who is clearly cosmetically enhanced”, etc… It is not necessarily a negative thing either. The positive side of this is that it has provided extra motivation for my wife’s fitness regimen; which is generally a good thing.

    “Cliquism”, which is a form of tribalism, can give rise to more negative judgement towards others “outside” of the clique. As “one version” of nudist ethos is adopted by the group, those who do not subscribe to it are judged for it; and sometimes outright rejected. When my wife and I started making friends at our resort, we found that we inadvertently had “joined” a clique. We then started gracefully distancing ourselves from them. We prefer to socialize with a broader spectrum of people, with the understanding that their “version” of nudism might differ from ours; and it’s ok as long as we’re all respectful towards each other

  6. another wonderful and humorous article. We judge people all the time, naturist environment or not and I freely admit at laughing to myself about someone wearing Crocs and socks, nothing else.

  7. In Christian circles we often hear, “Judge not, lest ye be judged.” And with many sorts of judgment, this is necessary. Yet in the same Sermon on the Mount, Jesus also said, “Ye shall know them by their fruit.” And that’s the *discernment* you mentioned.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *