| | |

Kind to Your Face, Cruel to Your Existence

When Nudity Is Used to Tell People They Don’t Belong

Naturism and respect. An open welcoming hand casting a shadow that points a finger a warmly lit wall.

You can be perfectly polite to someone while actively advocating a world in which they have less freedom, less acceptance, and less opportunity to live openly.

A video made the rounds in naturist circles a couple of months ago. We wonโ€™t name the man who made it, and we wonโ€™t link to it. Every click helps him, and frankly, we donโ€™t see any reason to send more traffic his way.

We had heard the name in naturism but hadnโ€™t had the pleasure of seeing a video by him. We have even had people post links to his teachings in comments on our website. Based on the one video we watched, we wonโ€™t be watching any others.

His message was simple. The human body, he argued, is made in Godโ€™s image, and it is being โ€œco-optedโ€ and โ€œhijackedโ€ by LGBTQ people. His answer was that Christian naturists should use nudity to push back and promote what he called his Godโ€™s morality.

We could write a long rebuttal. Instead, we want to talk about something that stuck with us more than the message itself.

The Same Man, Two Rooms

Weโ€™ve heard he is warm in person, that he treats gay and trans people with courtesy and kindness. And then, in front of an audience on video, he calls their relationships an abomination and says many of them are evil.

It is tempting to say one of those must be the โ€œrealโ€ him. We donโ€™t think thatโ€™s right. In his framework, there is no contradiction. You can be kind to the person and condemn the behavior. Love the person, reject the choice.

But hereโ€™s the problem we have with this, and itโ€™s the whole point of this article. The person on the receiving end doesnโ€™t experience it that way.

Someone who hears that their relationship is an abomination doesnโ€™t feel respected because the speaker was polite about it. Politeness is a manner. The message is the content. And the message is the part that travels. It reaches people who will never meet the kind version of him. Some of them will act on it.

Weโ€™ve had this conversation before. When a reader once told us, โ€œI donโ€™t hate anyone,โ€ we took them at their word. And we still pointed out that framing people the way they had can make already vulnerable people feel unsafe, even in spaces that claim to welcome everyone.

People often defend harmful statements by explaining what they intended. They didnโ€™t mean to offend anyone. They donโ€™t hate anybody. They were simply expressing their beliefs. But intentions donโ€™t erase consequences. There is an important distinction between being misunderstood and refusing to acknowledge the effect of your words.

If someone tells you that your words make them feel unwelcome, you have a choice. You can listen and consider what theyโ€™re saying, or you can insist that because you meant well, theyโ€™re wrong to feel that way.

The second response puts protecting your self-image ahead of understanding another person.

Nudity Is a State

Nudity is a state. Sex is an activity. Naturism asks only that you be comfortable in your own skin and let others be comfortable in theirs. It does have some underlying values: respect, acceptance, personal freedom, and consideration for others. But it has no opinion on who you love, who you vote for, or what god you believe in.

That is why the video bothered us so much. It took something simple, a body without clothes, and turned it into a campaign tool. The video even doubled as a plug for his Patreon. The body became a weapon in a cause. And once nudity is used to promote a moral agenda against a group of people, it stops being naturism. It becomes a costume for something else.

We said in our article on naturism and inclusivity that if your upbringing, religion, or politics are teaching you to hate someone simply for who they are, itโ€™s time for an honest look in the mirror. We still mean that. This is the other side of the same coin: itโ€™s just as wrong to use our philosophy as the vehicle.

Back view of a tattooed woman with wavy brown hair standing topless in a sunlit meadow.

This Is Not About Faith

We want to be fair, because this is easy to get wrong.

Plenty of Christians disagree with him, including Christian naturists. One reader told us heโ€™s a naturist because of what the Bible teaches, not in spite of it, and described a friendship with a fellow naturist who held very different views. They didnโ€™t agree, and they left as friends. Thatโ€™s a very different thing from turning your nudity into a campaign.

The issue isnโ€™t that someone believes their religion provides a moral framework. The issue is when they use that framework to determine whether another person deserves acceptance in a shared naturist environment.

There is a difference between saying, โ€œMy faith teaches me that this is wrong,โ€ and saying, โ€œYour existence is incompatible with what this community should represent.โ€

Christian naturism is perfectly legitimate. So is Muslim naturism, atheist naturism, or naturism practised by people of any other faith or belief system. People bring their personal beliefs with them. Thatโ€™s normal. People are welcome to express their faith while naked. But using naturism as a platform to promote a message that tells certain people they donโ€™t belong is when we have issue.

And this applies equally to secular beliefs.

A naturist who believes only certain body types are acceptable, or that people with tattoos, piercings, cosmetic surgery, or other perceived imperfections donโ€™t represent natural bodies, is doing something remarkably similar.

Gatekeeping doesnโ€™t need a pulpit. The urge to decide who is acceptable in a space that was supposed to be about acceptance isnโ€™t belief.

The Damage Isnโ€™t Limited to the People Being Targeted

Imagine being a gay or transgender person attending a naturist gathering. You hear someone publicly describe people like you as immoral, an abomination, or evil.

Even if nobody directs those words at you personally, how comfortable are you going to feel taking your clothes off around those people?

Naturism involves vulnerability. Youโ€™re physically exposed, often in an environment where trust and acceptance are particularly important. You shouldnโ€™t have to wonder whether someone sitting beside you at a campfire considers your existence morally objectionable.

And hereโ€™s the broader consequence: other people hear those messages too. Someone who might otherwise have considered naturism may decide it isnโ€™t a place where they would be welcome.

That means this isnโ€™t simply an issue between one speaker and the people he criticizes. It affects the entire community.

Topless woman with sunglasses standing in the ocean

What a Welcoming Space Looks Like

A welcoming naturist space doesnโ€™t ask for your politics at the gate. It doesnโ€™t hand out moral tests. It doesnโ€™t need you to agree with anyone about anything except one thing: that bodies are not shameful, and that everyone elseโ€™s body isnโ€™t either.

But we think thereโ€™s a distinction between not requiring ideological agreement and having no community standards. A naturist club, resort, park, or gathering has every right to establish expectations for respectful behaviour. You can welcome people with different beliefs while still making it clear that harassment, discrimination, intimidation, and targeted condemnation of other members arenโ€™t acceptable.

In fact, weโ€™d argue that a genuinely inclusive community has an obligation to do exactly that. Otherwise, inclusivity becomes little more than a pleasant slogan that offers no protection when somebody is made to feel unwelcome.

You can disagree with someone and still share a sauna, a beach, or a campfire. What you canโ€™t do, if you want to call it naturism, is use that shared space to tell some of the people in it that theyโ€™re a problem to be fixed.

Put plainly: you cannot claim to welcome someone into a community while publicly arguing that something fundamental about who they are makes them unacceptable.

Being kind to someone when theyโ€™re standing in front of you is a good thing. But respect isnโ€™t measured only by how you treat someone in a private conversation. Itโ€™s also measured by what youโ€™re willing to say about them when theyโ€™re not in the room.

You can be pleasant to someoneโ€™s face while making the world a little less welcoming to their existence. Those two things can coexist.

But we shouldnโ€™t confuse kindness in person with respect in public.

Kevin and Corin

Ournaturistlife.com


Everything we write and post is always free. If youโ€™d like to support what we do, you can choose a monthly supporter subscription or a one time donation through Ko-fi. It helps fuel our late-night naked potato-salad-fuelled rants!

Blue graphic thanking supporters whose donations and subscriptions keep content free for the naturist community, with a Ko-fi logo.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Similar Posts

5 Comments

  1. Well I love to be naked all the time and I am glad I have found others like me. Thatโ€™s considered strange in most circles. But it is something I have always loved to do and this year I have embraced it and told my family what I am. So there should be no judgment in our circle and anyone who does, they should look in the mirror.

  2. It’s quite fascinating where judgement begins and ends. One thing that seems consistent over the years about naturism is the various interpretations of it and what people think it should and shouldn’t be.

    Many years ago at a known public clothing optional space I became conscious of what I suspected was questionable behaviour.

    An interesting thought occurred to me though. Within that shared space why would my values and standards be any more or less important than anyone else’s?

    It was a troubling thought because it posed the question, โ€œWhere does judgement begin and end?”

    Based on personal interpretation of beliefs, people act in good faith to right what they perceive is wrong. They are however acting upon their personal worldview.

    The question is what makes their worldview more important than anyone else’s?

    I asked myself a different question. “Is there a need for me to be offended?”

    The simple answer was no. I’d have to go out of my way for that to occur. I simply carried on with my day taking with me a deep insight into acceptance and judgement.

    The main reason society rejects nudity and finds it offensive is based purely on a worldview they inherited and never questioned or challenged.

    Those of us who have questioned it and adjusted our worldview accordingly now experience the frustration of people’s lack of understanding and resulting judgement.

    This is what I feel each individual who has embarked on the naturist journey should reflect on. “Who am I to judge others?”

    It’s one of the fundamental faults within the world and the root cause of so much conflict, disagreement and grief.

  3. Thank you so much for this. After i came out, I avoided returning to naturism for about 20 years because I had a sense that the nudist community didn’t want LGBT people. About 10 years ago I started getting back into it. I have seen the video (thank you for not throwing more clicks their way). It was apalling and cruel. Because several podasts/nudist blogs sent a lot of traffic toward the creator and were silent on his statement, I unsubscribed. I am thrilled I made the coice to stay with you! Inclusive and accepting voices are so important if we want social nudism to grow.

  4. I agree with all this, Kevin and Corin. And I will add that my Christian faith compels me to welcome LGBTQ+ folk and speak for their right to “life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness” including the right to share our freedom and comfort. No form of exclusion has any place in my faith or public comments.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *